Credibility
Whether what someone says holds up. It comes from knowing the subject, getting the details right, being honest about where their knowledge stops, and a history of calls that turned out to be correct. It’s also where most people over-invest: piling on credentials is the most common way people try to earn trust, and the least effective.
“Do I believe what this person tells me?”
When it’s the weak one: they’re pleasant and on time, but you quietly double-check whatever they tell you.